Explain Codes LogoExplain Codes Logo

Identity increment is jumping in SQL Server database

sql
identity-cache
trace-flags
database-configuration
Nikita BarsukovbyNikita BarsukovยทOct 4, 2024
โšกTLDR

Facing identity gaps in SQL Server? Likely due to IDENTITY_CACHE. After each restart, sequences inadvertently jump. Override this by switching off Identity Cache in SQL Server 2017 and onwards:

-- Run like the wind. Wave to identity cache as you rush past ๐Ÿ˜„ ALTER DATABASE SCOPED CONFIGURATION SET IDENTITY_CACHE = OFF;

This secures a smooth run of identity values, but possible performance slowdowns due to disk-bound value retrievals await.

For a holistic solution, dive deeper below.

The Cache Game - understanding identity cache

Ever witnessed a squirrel storing nuts for winter? SQL Server is somewhat similar when generating identity values โ€” storing them in batches. However, server restarts or crashes see these values vanish, culminating in gaps.

Size Matters - cache size and server versions

  • A squirrel buries 1,000 nuts for winter. Similarly, SQL Server 2012 defaults cache 1,000 values for int identity columns.
  • Just as a smart squirrel plans storage, SQL Server 2017 allows identity cache control: ALTER DATABASE SCOPED CONFIGURATION.

Tracing the Trail - trace flags and sequences

  • With trace flag 272, one can log identity allocation. So, the mysterious case of increment jumps post-restart, resolved!
  • Bring**

In-Sequence Chronicles - alternative strategies for gapless increment

The Sequence Saviour

Stubborn identity columns giving you a headache? A sequence generator with NOCACHE option might be your perfect Advil.

Reseeding: The Greenhouse Effect

Unable to disable identity cache or use sequences? Welcome to the gardening club โ€” get your green thumbs on with some reseed options:

  • The green thumb's best friend is the DBCC CHECKIDENT โ€” handily resetting the identity value after restarts.
  • Those automated sprinklers seem nifty, right? Similarly, implement a stored procedure to water reseeding on startup.

Word of caution: grow your garden mindfully to avoid thorny issues of contention and performance.

Deja-Vu: gaps in legacy systems

Stuck in a time loop with SQL Server 2008R2? Fret not, trace flag 272 is not a time traveler. Instead:

  • The green thumb strikes again โ€” manually work on reseeding after a server restart.
  • Rely on your application-level strategy to handle potential time loops โ€” oops, I mean gaps.

Practicality over Mystery - dealing with real-world implications

When the gap gets real

In the universe of financial systems or legal numbering, gaps are unwanted aliens.

Speed Bumps - performance considerations

Beware! Disabling identity cache might lead to increased I/O, impacting INSERT performance. It's a hare and tortoise race!

The Forbidden Fruit - security constraints

Non-admins might taste the forbidden fruit of reseeding, but must beware of security implications and potential multi-user conflicts. Remember, not all apples lead to enlightenment!

Detective's Toolbox - troubleshooting and monitoring

Trail of Patches - applying trace flags

Mystery solvers apply trace flag 272 to startup parameters, a magical ritual that requires a server restart.

The Magnifying Glass - diagnostic queries

Who said SQL Server scripts only monitor behavior like replication backlog? They can also detect minute irregularities in identity value generation and act as mighty diagnostic tools.