Find string between two substrings

Alternative methods

Using indexes and slices to get the job done

Alright, let's say you're regex-phobic. No problem! Python's index and rindex functions can also put in the work:

s = 'your_text_here'
start_marker = 'start_marker'
end_marker = 'end_marker'

# The logic is simple: Find the markers, add their length, slice the content between them.
start_index = s.index(start_marker) + len(start_marker)
end_index = s.index(end_marker, start_index)  # From last start marker
substring = s[start_index:end_index]  # Cut the slice. Yum!


Remember here folks, the index function is a tricky beast. If it doesn't find your marker, it will raise a ValueError. Always prepare an escape route.

Crafting your own helper function

You might need to do this a lot. So why not create a find_between function to help out:

def find_between(s, start, end):
    """Sorry regex, we're doing this old-school."""
    try:
        start_index = s.index(start) + len(start)
        end_index = s.index(end, start_index)
        return s[start_index:end_index]
    except ValueError:
        # When life gives you ValueErrors
        return "No match found. But hey, it's better than an error, right?"


Dealing with all the things that could go wrong

What if the start marker appears more than once? We've got it covered. Use rindex to find the last occurrence of the end marker:

end_index = s.rindex('end_marker', start_index)  # From the last start marker to the end of the string.


One piece of advice, overusing index and rindex can lead to unexpected predictions. Always use them judiciously.

When you should prefer regex

Flexing your regex muscles

When your fun string extraction grows into complex patterns, regex begins to show its real power. With Python's re module, you can construct expressions to handle varying white spaces, case sensitivity, optional substrings, and many other aspects that plain string methods will find challenging.

Efficiency matters

You might be tempted to use split, but hold your horses. Don't split unnecessarily, especially with large strings. Splitting the entire text and then finding the relevant piece is like finding a needle in a haystack. re.search is akin to using a metal detector.

Mastering the art of regex

Regex is like a good wine: complex, robust, and gets better with practice. Learn to use character classes, quantifiers, and groupings:

result = re.search('start_marker([A-Za-z]+)end_marker', 'your_text_here')
print(result.group(1) if result else None)  # Prints only alphabetical characters between the markers


Advanced gimmicks and tricks

Custom extraction functions

For frequent extraction tasks, crafting custom extraction functions is advisable. Like a well-trained beachcomber, ensure your function handles errors gracefully and is tested against all sorts of weird text markings.

Exploring Python’s in-built toolbox

Python's built-in string methods like startswith, endswith, partition, and rpartition can often outshine regex or custom solutions. They're like the Swiss Army knife of string manipulation.

Getting fancy with negative slicing

If you need to exclude characters around your markers, negative slicing is your best bet:

offset = 1  # Characters around the target to omit.
substring = s[start_index+offset:end_index-offset]
