Difference between textContent vs innerText
textContent
retrieves all text within a node, including script
and style
content, ignoring styling. innerText
considers styles, thus ignoring scripts, styles, and hidden text and it updates layout when accessed, potentially impacting performance.
Here's a quick example:
textContent
is fast and efficient, while innerText
is style-conscious.
Detailed Differences
Speed and Efficiency
When it’s a race for speed, textContent
wins. innerText
causes a reflow - the browser's way of recalculating page layout. This can slow down performance, particularly with large documents or frequent dynamic content changes.
Universal Support vs Selective Support
textContent
is the universal soldier being supported across all node types and modern browsers, whereas innerText
only plays well with HTMLElement
. For the antique browsers (Hello, IE8!), polyfills using nodeValue
offer a fallback solution.
Depositing a Line Break and Layout Sensitive
innerText
has an eye for style and layout. It interprets visual formatting like <br>
tags and CSS display: none;
, providing the straightforward, human-readable text. On the other hand, textContent
wears layout blinders, returning the raw textual content inside an element.
Picking the Right Tool
Setting Element Text
If you have the mission of getting or setting content in both HTMLElement
and non-HTMLElement nodes like text nodes, textContent
is your go-to guy. It doesn't care if an element is hidden by CSS or not; it delivers the full text on demand.
Unearthing Large Textual Treasures
If you're dealing with a text mine of nodes, or frequent content updates, textContent
should top your list of text extraction tools for better performance and less CPU usage.
Unraveling the Invisible
If your job involves invisible elements but you still need to access their text, textContent
can sense the invisible and retrieve or modify the text irrespective of the visibility cloak.
Advanced Uses and Tricks
Creating New Text Nodes
If you’re crafting new text nodes using document.createTextNode()
, textContent
is an indispensable ally for smoothly embedding the created text within your document.
Reading Text Reflecting CSS Display
When your requirement is to obtain text as it's shown to the user, respecting CSS rules, then innerText
is your ticket. It faithfully delivers only visible text as per the CSS styling on the page.
Pro Tips and Gotchas
Leveraging Object.defineProperty
for textContent
To make textContent
toe the line in all scenarios, particularly in data-binding or reactive UI frameworks, Object.defineProperty
is a magic wand.
Making Accessibility a Priority
While both properties serve accessibility purposes, textContent
may include hidden text which could confuse assistive technologies. But innerText
plays safe by providing a text representation suited to the user's visual experience.
Add More to Your Toolkit
Expand your interpretative repertoire with resources like Kelly Norton's blogpost for a deep dive into the innerText
and textContent
comparison, or peruse perfectionkills.com for a table-wise breakdown.
Was this article helpful?