What is the difference between @Inject and @Autowired in Spring Framework? Which one to use under what condition?
In a nutshell, @Autowired
and @Inject
both give rise to dependency injection in Spring. However, pick @Autowired
for Spring exclusives, e.g. optional dependencies, and @Inject
for Java standards alignment. โ๏ธ
@Autowired
enables tuning in Spring, as seen with required=false
, absent in @Inject
:
@Autowired
: //I'm flexible, you don't always need me ๐
@Inject
: // either in or out, no room for maybe's ๐ง
Both annotations are processed by the AutowiredAnnotationBeanPostProcessor in Spring, ensuring your beans get their dose of dependency injection.
Dependency Injection Exposed
@Inject
originates from the Java CDI (Contexts and Dependency Injection) standard, also known as JSR-330. It's the "Java-universal" sign asking for dependency injection.
However, @Autowired
is the Spring centric annotation, extending beyond @Inject
its capabilities to @Qualifier
, @Primary
, and the much-coveted required
attribute.
@Inject's Ideal Use-Cases:
โจ Wide Usability: Your application should remain portable across various DI frameworks.
๐ฟ Alignment with Standards: Configuration values from both Spring and non-Spring sources are in use.
@Autowired's Time to Shine:
๐ช Rich Spring Features: Advanced features and the application of specialized Spring annotations are needed.
๐ฏ Complex Management: A multitude of bean instances or complex dependency management is needed.
@Autowired and @Inject - In Action
The Magic of Optional Dependencies
@Autowired
defies the odds by handling missing beans without impeding context startup:
@Autowired
: // "Ah, relax! Who needs dependencies all the time!" ๐
Lazy Injections with Provider<T>
@Inject
gets one up with Provider
, bringing you instances on demand:
@Inject
: // "Stay lazy, you get it when you need it!" ๐
The Superiority of Specificity with Qualifiers
@Autowired
takes your specificity to a new level when multiple implementations of an interface come into play, thanks to @Qualifier
:
@Autowired
: // "Look at me, I'm the captain now!" ๐ค
Trading Off with @Inject and @Autowired
Every choice has its pros and cons:
@Inject's Edge:
- ๐ Standard Alignment: Promotes portability and interoperability.
- ๐ Framework-Independent: Simplifies migration or polyglot management.
@Autowired's Advantage:
- ๐ ๏ธ Extensive Functionality: Taps into the wealth of the Spring framework.
- ๐ Varied Dependency Management: Handles intricate injection scenarios, like optional dependencies and qualifiers.
The Co-existence of Java EE and Spring
With Java EE 6, @Inject
was launched as a part of JSR-299 for CDI, which found support in Spring. However, with Spring 3.0 and higher versions, you get the best of Spring, served with a side of @Autowired
, offering much-desired familiarity to Spring developers.
Was this article helpful?