What causes and what are the differences between NoClassDefFoundError and ClassNotFoundException?

java

class-loading

class-not-found-error

no-classdeffounderror

byNikita Barsukov·Oct 19, 2024

When NoClassDefFoundError shows up, Java Virtual Machine (JVM) can't find a compiled class file at runtime, despite being there during compilation. This error is mostly due to misconfigured classpath or moved .class files.

ClassNotFoundException, however, is an exception that pops up when an application tries to dynamically load a class (through Class.forName(), ClassLoader.loadClass(), etc.) and fails because the .class file is not found in the classpath at runtime.

Here's a quick rundown:

NoClassDefFoundError: Missing class issue due to runtime classpath problem.

// An example of the error you might see:
Error: Could not find or load main class MyClass //Hmm, where did I put my class again?

ClassNotFoundException: Dynamic loading failure when the class is not found.

// How you might encounter the exception:
try {
  Class.forName("my.package.NonExistentClass");
} catch (ClassNotFoundException e) {
  e.printStackTrace(); //Guess I'll just.. print this..on my own
}

The core difference: build-time presence vs runtime absence causes NoClassDefFoundError, while runtime absence during dynamic loading triggers ClassNotFoundException.

Going deeper: Practical differences and resolutions

Locating the error source

NoClassDefFoundError can be traced back to class loading. Examining your build process, like the build.xml files, can make sure classes aren't missing post-compilation. For this error, static initializers and members might be trouble if they throw exceptions or fail to resolve.

Whereas, ClassNotFoundException points to a loss with dynamic class loading. It often signifies a class not found by name in the classpath during runtime. To dodge this, ensure the specific class is present in the CLASSPATH. Tools like jarFinder or jarscan can be helpful to identify the JAR that houses a missing class.

Handling the "sticky" behavior of `NoClassDefFoundError`

NoClassDefFoundError is like that grumpy cat, which once irritated, throws tantrums unapologetically. Once JVM encounters this error during the classloading phase, it might remember the failed attempt. Subsequent, similar irritants could provoke the same error within that JVM session.

Resolving class visibility in complex environments

Complex build environments or application servers may bring visibility issues of classes across different classloaders to surface. To beat the NoClassDefFoundError, verifying whether a class should be loaded by some parent classloader can mitigate the class visibility issue.

Recoverability

ClassNotFoundException is like a knock on the door that can be handled. Actions to recover, such as alternative class names or logging detailed information for further analysis, can be taken once it happens. However, NoClassDefFoundError is more like a house on fire - a critical situation asking for immediate change in the application's environment or configuration.

Working solutions: Step-by-step

In a NoClassDefFoundError situation:

Check your classpath: Verify all important JARs are thoughtfully included.
Inspect static blocks: Encountering exceptions thrown from middle of nowhere (static initializers) or an elusive static field which fails to resolve isn't fun.
Investigate the class file: Use decompiling tools like JAD to perform a thorough checkup.
Resolve version conflicts: Make sure your dependencies are all on the same page using a tool like Maven or Gradle.

Handling ClassNotFoundException:

Revisit CLASSPATH: Cross-check that the class name spelled is correct and exists where it should.
Turn to advanced classloading: In times of need, getting to know custom classloaders for programmatic loading can save the day.
Ensure build configs are thorough: Are your build tools and scripts really including all classes?
Scour your environment: Keep an eye out for differences between development and production environments that can affect classpath settings.

Developer notes: Preventive measures

Play safe with NoClassDefFoundError: Keep an eagle eye on your manifest files, build scripts, and environment configurations. Regularly clean and rebuild projects to avoid making NoClassDefFoundError a regular house guest.

Stay ahead of ClassNotFoundException: With the widespread use of Java's reflection API, a good understanding of dynamic class loading can boost your debugging progress.

explain-codes / Java / What causes and what are the differences between NoClassDefFoundError and ClassNotFoundException?

Linked

Why am I getting a NoClassDefFoundError in Java?



How to run a class from Jar which is not the Main-Class in its Manifest file



Java SecurityException: signer information does not match



Ant warning: "'includeantruntime' was not set"



How to run a JAR file

