Should I use Java date and time classes or go with a 3rd party library like Joda Time?

Deep dive into Java Time API

The java.time package (Java 8 onward) is a quantum leap over the old java.util.Date and .Calendar. It enhances your date-time manipulations with immutability and a fluent, intuitive API layout.

Date-time handling realities

The intricate dance of date and time can turn into a Herculean challenge, especially for global systems grappling with time zones, daylight saving time and calendar systems. Thankfully, java.time API and Joda-Time are your trusty sidekicks in this adventure.

Immutability and thread safety, not an oxymoron

Both java.time API and Joda-Time offer immutable date-time classes—a godsend for thread safety and application predictability.

DateTime dt = new DateTime(); // Joda-Time, because threads just wanna have fun.
ZonedDateTime zdt = ZonedDateTime.now(); // Java Time API, dancing with threads in style and safety.


Time zone handling, not a "zone of doom"

Joda-Time wins hearts with robust, reliable, and comprehensive time zone support. It goes the extra mile with independent timezone database updates, only possible because Joda-Time doesn't run on coffee breaks, unlike some other JDK components.

DateTimeZone zone = DateTimeZone.forID("America/New_York"); // Joda-Time, not just a timezone, it's a lifestyle.
ZoneId zoneId = ZoneId.of("America/New_York"); // Java Time API, bringing New York time to your console, minus the hustle.


Parsing and formatting made fun

Both libraries offer great parsing and formatting functionality. Even fancy, unconventional formats tremble before their might. Joda-Time's formatter classes are thread-safe and reusable—kind of like reusing jokes, but funnier.

DateTimeFormatter formatter = DateTimeFormat.forPattern("dd/MM/yyyy HH:mm"); // Joda-Time, transforming gibberish to gold.
DateTimeFormatter formatter = DateTimeFormatter.ofPattern("dd/MM/yyyy HH:mm"); // Java Time API, time now has an accent.


Swimming upstream with extensibility and calendar systems

Joda-Time is a rockstar for alternative calendar systems, a lifesaver for non-Gregorian scenarios. Java Time API, a Joda-Time fan, also features this, but Joda-Time's library would put any rock festival to shame.

CopticChronology coptic = CopticChronology.getInstance(); // Joda-Time, doing dates the Pharaoh way.
Chronology coptic = CopticChronology.INSTANCE; // Java Time API, because you don't just mess with Pharaohs.


The dry martini initialization

Joda-Time earns brownie points for its elegant initialization methods for day-to-day date-time operations. The built-in classes feel more like making coffee without a coffee-maker.

LocalDate christmas = new LocalDate(2023, 12, 25); // Joda-Time, full steam ahead to Christmas!
LocalDate christmas = LocalDate.of(2023, Month.DECEMBER, 25); // Java Time API, no reindeers were harmed in the making of this date.


Time zone nightmares, no more

Joda-Time and the java.time API both offer mechanisms to keep your app current with always-changing time zone rules. Handy for globetrotter applications!

Parsing the unparsable

Parsing often leads to head-scratching errors, but Joda-Time sports a super-spidey sense for advanced error management during parsing. Clear, succinct feedback helps you course-correct quickly, saving much of your grey matter.

From old to new (yes, you can teach old dogs new tricks)

Stephen Colebourne, Joda-Time’s creator, led the JSR-310 effort, leading to the java.time package. You could say Java 8's date and time classes consumed a dose of Joda-Time elixir. Hence, upgrading from Joda-Time to java.time.* package feels like homecoming.

Remember the cardinal rule: Do not reinvent the calendar wheel. With powerhouses like Joda-Time and java.time.*, you have the tools of Time Lords at your disposal.