How to fix Hibernate LazyInitializationException: failed to lazily initialize a collection of roles, could not initialize proxy - no Session

Relation between @Transactional and Session

The art of dealing with LazyInitializationException heavily relies on defining transaction boundaries. Let's explain it using @Transactional. Spring ensures to keep the session open during the whole time a @Transactional decorated method is running:

// Let's kick off an authentication party!
@Transactional
public User authenticate(String username) {
    User user = userRepository.findByUsername(username);
    // The roles collection is inside of this method. Groovy!
    return user;
}


The right placement of @Transactional makes all the difference by ensuring the session is active when Hibernate tries to lazily load associations.

Using JOIN FETCH and DTOs

Eager fetch may not be the best solution every time. You might like to use JOIN FETCH in your JQPL queries to fetch the entities right when you need them, no sooner, no later:

// Your wish is my query!
@Query("SELECT u FROM User u JOIN FETCH u.roles WHERE u.id = :id")
User findUserAndRolesById(@Param("id") Long id);


Meanwhile, DTO projection can pluck out only the data you need without touching whole entities. DTOs aim at reducing database load and preventing, on the design level, the LazyInitializationException:

public UserDTO getUserDTO(Long id) {
    User user = findUserAndRolesById(id);
    // Uhu! DTO to the rescue for carrying no heavy entities.
    return new UserDTO(user);
}


This approach is more flexible and efficient in terms of transferring data, and helps in navigating around various lazy loading traps.

Optimization with retrieval strategies

On the other side, bear in mind that enabling Open Session in View or "hibernate.enable_lazy_load_no_trans" could impact your application's performance. They might seem to solve issues in a snap but can lead to performance barriers in the long run. An effective way is to design around the problem using DTOs or fetching strategies based on a deep understanding of Hibernate's session management.

Deepening understanding

You can increase performance through:

• Performance analysis: A granular exploration of how collections are used in your application can light up when and where eager or lazy fetching might be the best choice.
• Testing: Testing helps ensure your @Transactional placement doesn't cause LazyInitializationException in your tests.
• Entity within boundary: Entities being fully initialized within the transaction boundary prevent exceptions.
• Layered architecture: A thoughtful layered architectural design can minimize dependency on lazy loading, resulting in a more resilient and maintainable codebase.

Weighing up trade-offs

Knowing the implications of your chosen strategies is key:

• Long-term solutions: Performance and maintainability should be considered when selecting fetching strategies. An eager fetch can fix the problem immediately, but at a price: overbearing memory consumption.
• Anti-patterns: Familiarize yourself with the impact of enabling the Open Session in View filter or similar configurations. Consider their potential performance implications.
• The flexibility of JOIN FETCH: Join fetch gives you scope to fetch associated entities only when needed without affecting all queries.