Entity Framework error: Cannot insert explicit value for identity column in table
Entity Framework (EF) identity insert issues can be addressed by marking your entity’s ID as being generated by the database. Use Data Annotations thus:
Or Fluent API:
Ensure your ID property isn't assigned a value before performing save operations—let the database take care of that.
Syncing EF model with your database
1. Reflecting database changes in your EF model
When your database changes, align your EDMX (Entity Data Model XML) to properly reflect these modifications. This can prevent mismatches between your EF Designer settings and the actual database structure. Make sure your Identity properties are set to increment automatically.
2. Set IsDbGenerated properly
Examine your EF designer file for IsDbGenerated=true on your identity column. Who you gonna call when it's missing? You, by adding the [DatabaseGenerated(DatabaseGeneratedOption.Identity)] attribute to the entity's Class Property yourself!
3. Let the database be in control
Identity columns should be left for the Database to populate. There's no need to assign explicit values in your code. Let the big DB in the sky (aka your server 💻) handle the job!
Comprehensive guide for EF setup pro tips
1. A firm understanding of your ID property
Setting the database to auto-increment isn't enough. Make sure your ID property in EF models correctly aligns with the identity column in the database.
2. Feud detector: conflicting settings
Double-check your data and look for reserved IDs that might roll up to a fistfight with newly generated values. Synchronize your EF configurations with the database's identity properties to avoid errors during insertion.
3. Save changes securely
After adding your new entity and modifying your DbContext, _groupContext.SaveChanges() comes in as the superhero to save the day (and to actually save your changes into the database).
Troubleshoot like a pro
1. When to consider dropping and recreating tables
Stuck in a time loop of never-ending identity insert conflicts? Break the cycle by dropping the problematic table and re-running the scripts to recreate it. Be sure to include the identity settings that were previously missing in this new script.
2. EF Code First? We got you covered!
Those employing EF Code First, ensure you're using the [Key] attribute along with [DatabaseGenerated]. Kick things up a notch by auto-generating GUIDs with [DefaultValue("newid()")].
3. Updating strategies aren’t just for game plans
Routinely syncing your database and EF design settings is crucial to avoid possible conflicts. Sometimes, manually updating attributes in the EDMX design file is necessary for a successful operation.
Code and methodology checks
1. Double-check DbContext saving operations
When troubleshooting, keep an eye on how your code manages DbContext save operations. Mismanagement here can be the sneakiest root-cause of your woes.
2. Verify EF's database generation
Automatically-generated scaffolds are not infallible. When EF misses the "IsDbGenerated=true" attribute, adding it manually can get your code back on track.
Was this article helpful?