Declaring variables inside or outside of a loop

java

performance-tuning

variable-scope

optimization

byAnton Shumikhin·Oct 15, 2024

For maintainability, declare variables inside the loop if they're used strictly within the loop's body and don't save values between iterations:

for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
    int temp = i * 2;  //Temp is so hot right now
}

Declare outside the loop when you need the variable's value after the loop or across multiple iterations:

int sum = 0;  //Zero to hero!
for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
    sum += i;  //sum - collector of i-souls 
}

JVM has your back with making performance impact unnoticeable; focus on readability and keeping a tight leash on variable scope.

Playing it tight: Scope management and maintenance

Dealing with variable scope, a golden rule: keep your friends close and your variables closer. That is to say, if a variable is used only within a loop, its declaration belongs there too. This gives you scoping control and your future self will thank you during debugging.

for (int i = 0; i < n; i++) {
    Object item = list.get(i);  // Just borrowing item for a spin, will return soon
    // item's business ends here
}

Minimize the lifetime of your variables. Do this to encompass precisely when it's needed.

Performance tuning: Timing the optimization

Chasing shadows will get you nowhere. Premature optimization is one such shadow. Adopt the motto: Don't guess, measure!. Employ profiling tools to find the real performance bottlenecks.

Further, the inside vs outside debate on variable placement has minimal impact on JVM's bytecode generation. Thanks to JIT compilation and runtime optimizations, JVM treats variables in or outside loops more or less equally.

Spare the new, spoil the old: Object reuse

Immutable objects, such as strings, do tend to create a mess with new instances at every turn. Worry not, here declaring outside the loop can bail you out. However, prioritize getting your code structure right first, optimization can wait. Also, algorithmic optimizations often wave a bigger magic wand than micro-optimizations like variable placement.

What befalls the unwary: Common mistakes

When reusing objects outside of loops, ensure you're not unintentionally creating a where's my state? situation. Modifying an object during each iteration might lead to logical errors. Be aware when handling shared resources or modifying collection elements.

In scenarios where variables gradually accumulate values, like summing numbers or concatenating strings, external declaration is a must. Remember, know thy use-case well before locking and loading your variables.

StringBuilder builder = new StringBuilder();  //In builder we trust
for (String word : words) {
    builder.append(word);  //Hey words, get in line!
}

Tools on the belt: Profiling and benchmarking

Performance tuning? Look beyond the loop. Turn to tools like Google Caliper or JMH for accurate performance analysis. Beware of JVM optimizations skewing results of your manual tests—consider a dummy loop to prevent it.

Depth over breadth: Advanced resources

Consider extracurricular learning with technical blogs, code repositories, and stack-learnings. Mighty coders often share their war stories and mighty solutions. Great enhancement to your understanding of variable scope and performance optimization.

explain-codes / Java / Declaring variables inside or outside of a loop

Linked

Difference between declaring variables before or in loop?



When and how should I use a ThreadLocal variable?



Java synchronized method lock on object, or method?



Stringbuilder vs String Concatenation in toString() in Java



What are the differences between ArrayList and Vector?

