Explain Codes LogoExplain Codes Logo

Advantages of using prototype, vs defining methods straight in the constructor?

javascript
prototype-engineering
inheritance
performance
Alex KataevbyAlex Kataev·Jan 29, 2025
TLDR

Opt for prototype to conserve memory, as functions are shared amongst instances. In contrast, methods in the constructor are duplicated per instance, using more memory.

Prototype:

function Obj() {} Obj.prototype.sharedFunction = function() { /* Feeling a bit shared today */ };

Constructor:

function Obj() { this.specificFunction = function() { /* I'm unique, just like everyone else */ }; }

Consider prototype for lower memory footprint, and constructor when you require instance-specific methods.

One method to rule them all

In prototype, a change to a method is reflected across all instances. Your constructor-defined method is a rebellious teenager - ignoring global changes and insisting on its independence.

Keep in mind the importance of hoisting in JavaScript:

  • Function declarations are hoisted, made available throughout the scope.
  • Function expressions in variables are hoisted but left unassigned - like declaring intent without a plan. It's hoisted, but it doesn't do anything yet.

Trim the fat, boost performance

A constructor pattern without the prototype takes the scenic route for performance. It's a memory hog, creating separate function copies for each instance. It's like building a house — and the kitchen sink — from scratch each time!

Prototype chains foster shared inheritance, where a function is created once, then referenced by all instances, using less memory, boosting performance, and making your programs leaner than a French cookbook.

Debugging and override? Easy peasy!

Named function expressions can give more descriptive error output, making debugging a breeze compared to faceless functions lurking within constructors. Also, prototypical inheritance lets you override and call base methods effortlessly. Don't like a method? Just override it, no hard feelings!

Meet the parents: Inheritance and Access

While you can access private variables within the constructor like the secret diary of your class, prototype methods don't get this access pass. However, prototype methods do make it easy to invoke and override base methods, establishing clean, efficient inheritance structures.

The tollbooth: Load speed and efficiency

On the internet highway, less cargo (smaller, fewer scripts) ensures a faster, smoother ride. Using prototypes helps reduce load times by reducing your JavaScript cargo weight. So, buckle up and take the express lane with prototypes!

It's all private in the Constructor's club

Constructors can't access private prototype methods or properties. It's like a private party you weren't invited to. This can shape how you architect your object-oriented JavaScript code and decide between prototypes and constructors.

Balancing act: Encapsulation and flexibility

Constructor functions can achieve encapsulation using closures, orchestrating a private-public dance. Although prototypes require a little extra leg work for the same effect, they afford more flexibility, letting you easily swap and extend behaviours for more future-proof, maintainable code.